Best Crib Mattress Reviews 2017 – The Ultimate Guide

Hunting for a crib mattress can prove to be quite a task especially for first-timers. There are too many factors to consider as it is with almost everything that’s meant to be used by infants or toddlers. This article will focus on reviewing the best crib mattresses on the market and the factors to consider when buying a crib mattress as well as the types of crib mattresses.

 At the end of the day, every parent or caregiver wants the best for their infants or toddlers. You want a healthier mattress that’s super comfortable with best support and durability. And, we all want to get the best deal when it comes to quality and prices so you might want to make several comparisons on features and prices before settling for one. Babies spend an average of 16 hours sleeping in their cribs, so you want to make sure that the mattress is safe and comfortable.

Different crib mattresses will have different interior materials. As most people say, when it comes to mattresses, what’s on the inside says a lot about how comfortable the mattress is going to be, and this is also the case with crib mattresses.

There are three main types of crib mattresses:

Foam crib mattress

Foam crib mattresses are the cheapest because they are the most basic varieties of crib mattresses. The only contain blocks of foam hence why they are cheap. They are also very light thus making a great choice for those people with portable cribs because they are easily foldable.

There are however various types of materials that are used to make a foam mattress such as bamboo fiber, latex, and polyurethane. Each of these materials will determine the price of the mattress, how comfortable the mattress is going to be and also its durability. For example, polyurethane based foam mattress is cheap though it sinks faster while latex based foam mattress is more expensive but lasts longer.

 Again, the different foam materials will give the mattresses varying firmness levels and densities so you should keep this in mind as you shop.
PROS
  • Cheap
  • Lightweight and foldable
  • They are available in various sizes
  • CONS
  • They are less durable compared to other crib mattresses
  • Innerspring/Coil spring crib mattresses

    These mattresses’ core is made of coiled steel hence their name. Compared to foam mattresses, innerspring crib mattresses are heavier and firmer. However, be sure not to fall for some salesy phrases such as “more coils equals more firm or more comfortable mattress” as this is not true. The only thing determining the comfort and firmness level of an innerspring crib mattress is the gauge/thickness of the steel coils used. The ideal gauge is 15.5 and below. Basically, the lower the gauge, then the thicker the steel wire making up each coil.

     You should avoid cheaper coil spring mattresses because they are mostly made of poor quality spring coils thus making the mattress squeak with every movement.
    PROS
  • Innerspring mattresses are durable
  • Offers the best support and comfort
  • CONS
  • They are heavy
  • Expensive than foam mattresses
  • Pocket spring crib mattresses

    These mattresses too are made of steel coils as the inside material, but they differ in that each spring is sewn to its own material pocket rather than connecting to each other. They thus have individual pockets that allow each of the springs to move independently, so each spring compresses based on the amount of weight it’s supporting. This means that the mattress gives better support for the baby.

    PROS
  • Offers an excellent support
  • Very durable
  • Very comfortable
  • CONS
  • Pocket spring crib mattresses are quite expensive
  • Memory Foam Crib Mattresses

    If you are looking for a comfortable crib mattress, one made of memory foam could make a great choice. Memory foam material is temperature sensitive thus the mattress molds to the baby’s body shape to offer the best comfort. At first, a memory foam mattress feels firmer but it quickly contours to the baby’s curves once they lie on it.

    Most memory foam crib mattresses will feature a coiled spring core topped with memory foam, and this means you cannot flip it over. Thus, if the crib mattresses say double sided it probably lacks a spring core.

    PROS
  • Offers great comfort and support
  • It’s great for really cold seasons as it retains much of the body heat
  • Very durable
  • CONS
  • Might not be the best for warmer environments as it reduces air circulation thus sleeping hot
  • If it has a spring core, it cannot be flipped
  • Natural & organic crib mattresses

    The only way to completely avoid harsh chemicals found in most mattresses is to get a natural one. Most mattress types feature some petroleum by-products and other flame retardant chemicals, but you won’t find such in a natural crib mattress.

    Natural crib mattresses are made from all natural materials and fibers such as untreated wool to act as a dust mite resistant and natural flame retardant, organic cotton for breathability, natural latex to replace petroleum-based foams and coconut fiber for breathability as well.

     However, ensure that the mattress is all natural if it is advertised as so because some manufacturers only use just a little natural material then label the entire mattress as natural.
    PROS
  • Chemical free crib mattress
  • Very durable
  • Highly breathable
  • Gentle on allergies
  • CONS
  • The firmness level of a natural/organic crib mattress varies with the materials used
  • They are quite expensive
  • You will also to do extensive research before buying because these mattresses are not too common
  • Factors to consider when looking for the best crib mattress

    • Size

    The size of the crib mattress comes first. It should fit your crib perfectly, leaving no spaces as this could be dangerous for your little one.

    Also, be keen to check the corners and see if they are rounded or square shaped as this too determines how well it fits in the crib.
    • Breathability

    You want your baby to sleep cool because too much heat could lead to discomfort. This is why some kids sleep better in other places but their beds.

    • Waterproof

    With kids, accidents are bound to happen. Thus, ensuring that the cover material is waterproof gives you an easy time cleaning after your baby. Also, a waterproof cover material prolongs the durability of your crib mattress because it keeps liquids from reaching the inside material.

    • Stain-proof/resistant

    Sometimes you won’t be around to catch the spills just as they happen. Thus, you want to ensure that your crib mattress won’t have too many stains from spills by choosing a mattress whose cover material is stain proof/resistant.

    • Inside materials

    The inside materials determine so much about the mattress. Thus, based on your needs you can either choose foam, memory foam, innerspring or any other materials that meet your needs. The inside materials determine the mattress’ durability, support, firmness, price, and so on.

    • Harsh chemicals

    Be keen to see the type of chemicals used in the process of making the crib mattresses. Some are too harsh and exposing infants or toddlers to them could result in many health issues. Read customer reviews to see other buys’ experiences as well as the product descriptions to see what’s listed.

    • Firmness level

    Basically, infants need a firm mattress to avoid suffocation risks. What’s too firm for you might be the best for your baby so shop wisely.

    • Hypoallergenic crib mattress

    Hypoallergenic mattresses are those that are less allergenic. If your baby has sensitive skin or has been diagnosed with allergies or asthma, the last thing you want near them is a mattress that triggers the allergies. Hypoallergenic crib mattresses prevent irritation, and the babies sleep better.

    • Double-sided crib mattress

    While infants sleep better on really firm mattresses, toddlers could do better with a little softness. Thus, most people change their mattresses when their kids reach the toddler stage, but it is much more economical if you got a double sided mattress. One side is firmer than the other, so you just flip it when need be.

    • Weight

    Mostly, heavy mattresses are stubborn when it comes to changing sheets or cleaning them. Therefore, to have it easy, a lightweight crib mattress is better. However, be sure that you are not compromising on quality for lightweight.

    • Certification seals

    To ensure that you are getting a safe mattress for your little one, check for certifications as this shows that the mattress has undergone certain tests and it is safe for use by infants and toddlers.

    • Flame retardant

    Mattresses are really flammable, and they burn really quickly, and that’s why there are set flammability standards for crib mattresses. Flame retardant means that even if your mattress catches fire it will burn much slower and there is a higher chase of saving the baby. However, ensure that the chemicals used for flame retardant are not toxic as this could cause more dangers to your baby’s health.