Best Innerspring Mattress Reviews and Rating

Innerspring beds are probably the oldest types of mattresses we have today. Although latex and memory foam designs have taken the market by storm there’s still a large fraction of consumers who prefer sleeping on an innerspring bed.

Why you ask? 

Well, innerspring beds do not have a problem with overheating like most memory foam mattresses. Even with the bounce we all love, most of them have managed to eliminate the motion transfer problem.

But finding the ideal innerspring mattress can be a nerve wrecking experience. This is because of the few quality options available in a sea of brands. But we are here to help you. We’ve scoured the market, and prepared this list of the best innerspring mattresses.

In here, you’ll find great products with a ton of information about them. So, let’s jump right in best innerspring mattress chart.

Best innerspring mattress. Comparison table

Model

Innerspring System

Layers

Firmness

Price

768 individually wrapped coils

13-gauge

0.5-inch gel memory foam

1.25 inches comfort foam

0.5-inch fiber

0.75-inch comfort foam

8 inches wrapped innerspring coils

6.5/10 Medium-firm

13-gauge individually encased coils

1-inch gel memory foam

0.25-inches comfort foam layer

0.5-inch comfort foam

1-inch gel memory foam

2 inches comfort foam

0.75-inch comfort foam

8 inches individually wrapped coils

7.0/10 Medium-plush

iCoil system

1.5 inches memory foam

2.5 inches high-density memory foam

7.5 inches of coils

8.5/10 Extra Firm

532 continuous coil system

Serta XD comfort foam, insulator pad, and continuous springs base

6.5-7/10 Medium Firm

Pocketed springs

Airfeel foam, airflow foam, gel memory foam, and pocketed springs

6.5/10 Medium Firm

Individual springs

Plush top layer, foam middle layers, individual 3-zone springs

5.5/10 Medium

744, 13.5 gauge pocketed springs

1.6-inch pillow top

3-zone foam

10 inches pocketed springs

5.5/10 Medium

best innerspring mattress

Why it is the best innerspring mattress according to our review?

One of the key changes in innerspring beds is the integration of better cooling technology instead of just relying on the coil system. This is the case with the Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top hybrid mattress. It combines gel foam with cooling properties together with wrapped innerspring coils.

Construction 

Top layer

This bed utilizes a 5-layer design. First, we have the ventilated pillow top cover. It is very airy, and works well with the gel foam beneath it. The matching knit-sides offer a modern look for this mattress. It blends well with just any decor so you won’t have to go looking for matching paint.

The gel foam layer also equals as the comfort surface for this mattress. It is only a ½ –inch. This layer is slow to respond to pressure meaning it offers better pressure relief. You’ll like that it is cool since it is the layer that has gel beads. If you sleep hot, you may want to try this mattress since it promises better sleep in warm environments.

Middle layers

After the gel foam top, there are three layers that alternate comfort foam with fiber. These slabs provide extra comfort along with better transition towards the base layers. They offer a luxurious feeling as they lie directly above the coil spring system.

Foundation layer

At the foundation is 8 inches of wrapped innerspring coils. It features a 768 coil count of 13-gauge spring. When comparing mattresses, a low gauge number indicates that the springs are thick. This is the case with the Classic Brands Mercer mattress. The base makes it firmer than other spring beds, but it retains the comfy feeling thanks to the multiple foam layers.

The coils are in two layers to offer support to the heavier body parts. It makes for a good mattress for heavy sleepers since it maintains a good level of bounce. The pocketed coils are also durable so you can expect to pay a premium price to acquire this bed.

Firmness

As the low-gauge number indicates, this mattress has a firm feeling to it. But it is much softer at the top so you won’t have a problem with feeling the solid base. This mattress favors stomach and back sleepers more than it does for side sleepers.

Motion Transfer, Sinkage, and Edge Support 

Innerspring beds always have a problem with motion transfer because of the bounce created by innerspring. But the Classic Brands Mercer uses pocketed coils. It means that the springs move individually such that any motion experienced on one side of the bed becomes localized.

The comfort foam and fiber combine with the coils to prevent compression beyond a certain point. This indicates that the mattress resists too much sinkage so that you can float and switch positions with ease. It also goes to say that you’ll get excellent edge support as the thick coils reinforce the sides.

PROS

  • It has high durability levels
  • It uses high-quality CertiPUR Certified foam and a reliable coil system
  • The mattress comes rolled in a box for easy shipping
  • It is available in many sizes including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King
  • Quilted pillow top is naturally hypoallergenic
  • It has orthopedic support
  • CONS

  • It takes as many as 48 hours for the mattress to expand fully
  • The mattress cannot be flipped over
  • best innerspring mattress

    The Classic Brands Gramercy Euro Top is a more luxurious option. It is pricier and thicker than the Mercer model. It is available in the size you’d like with plush comfort to help you sleep deeply. It has both conforming properties of memory foam and the supportive elements of innerspring coils.

    Construction

    Cover

    The Gramercy features multiple layers to offer balanced comfort and support. It has a Euro Top box top along with a wrapped innerspring system. The six layers start with a quilted Euro Top cover. It is a flex-knit cover with high elasticity. This way, it will not bunch up if you turn a lot in your sleep. The sides are well-ventilated to help in overall heat dissipation.

    Top layer

    Below the cover is 1-inch cool gel memory foam integrated into the pillow top. It showcases some essential breathable properties which keep your sleeping climate conducive for uninterrupted sleep. At least with the ventilated foam, airflow increases and you won’t be dealing with hot sweaty nights.

    Middle layer

    Progressive comfort foam comes after the gel memory foam. It has better support and is more responsive to pressure. In this slab, the mattress benefits from orthopedic support as it helps to alleviate pain from pressure points. This is with the help of the 1-inch memory foam layer that comes directly after the comfort foam segment. With the soft memory foam, your body can transition better to the base layer.

    Foundation layer

    The supportive power of the Gramercy is by the 13 gauge individually wrapped coils. They provide precise contour to the body; hence you can get pressure relief on achy muscles. This area is also responsible for reduced motion transfer as the pocketed coils dampen any movement.

    Firmness

    This mattress boasts a medium-firmness level. It is more on the plush side because of the many layers of memory foam and comfort foam. If you like sleeping on your side, you are going to love the Gramercy. The contouring memory foam comes in handy to hug sensitive areas as well as fill the space you create on your lower back. Stomach and back sleepers will find that it spreads your weight evenly across the bed’s surface. Although it is lush on top, the 8-inch base ensures you’ll not sink and misalign the spine. It’s no wonder many people who suffer from back pain love sleeping on the Gramercy.

    Motion Transfer, Edge Support, and Sinkage 

    This bed lets you enjoy a more peaceful sleep owing to the layering and use of individual coils. This means that motion does not transfer from spring to spring such that bounce is not felt on every inch of the bed. It also excels in the sinkage area as it receives constant pushback from the springs.

     You can sleep on the edges of the Gramercy. This is because it is less susceptible to pressure. By layering different densities of memory foam and using wrapped coils, you will feel well-supported. Now you can tie your shoes comfortably while sitting aggressively on the edges of this bed.

    PROS

  • It maximizes support and comfort by using a Euro Top cover and spring support base
  • The gel infused memory foam helps to draw away heat to the outer layers of this bed
  • It has contouring properties that leave you fully rested
  • The medium firmness level favors all sleepers
  • It uses naturally hypoallergenic gel memory foam
  • It has a 10-year warranty against craftsmanship faults
  • CONS

  • It has an initial chemical smell
  • Some users have a problem with formation of indentations after sleeping on the mattress for a short time
  • best innerspring mattress

    Zinus have been producing some of the best mattresses on the market. Their model - Performance Plus is an extra firm bed that is the perfect for heavy sleepers, back and stomach sleepers. It is also a hybrid bed seeing that it combines high-quality foam with a durable base layer of wrapped coils.

    Construction

    Cover 

    Every bed needs a cover that is plush and comfy. The Zinus Performance Plus uses a soft knit jacquard Euro Top Box cover. It has temperature regulation and odor control properties. It absorbs moisture, leaving you dry. This way, your bed remains fresh every night. What’s more, it gives the bed beautiful aesthetics since it is all white with a knitted pattern.

    Top layer 

    This 12-inch bed comes in three layers. The top layer features 1.5 inches of memory foam. It provides contouring and cooling comfort. Because of this layer, heat from your body leaves fast and easy to the outside. The ventilated foam helps in temperature regulation to prevent heat buildup when sleeping directly on memory foam.

    Middle layer

    The middle layer is 2.5 inches of high-density memory foam. It is an integral part of this mattress as it works to prevent trapping of memory foam. It is also pressure resistant thus eliminating the buildup of stress on the critical points of the body. This way, you get universal sleep no matter the sleeping position you like.

    The high-density foam comes right after the comfort foam. It provides durability aspects on the upper layer of foam. This is because it helps the top to snap back and maintain its structure over time. The middle slab is also the transition layer that provides a soft landing for the body so you will never feel the direct pushback caused by the spring system.

    Base layer

    The base layer is 7.5 inches of individually wrapped coils. They offer extra support to the areas of the body you need most. It serves as the foundation of this bed where it retains the shape of this bed. The Queen-size bed has a high coil count of 768 coils. The high number indicates that this bed is much firmer than many beds with a high firmness level. 

    best innerspring mattress

    Firmness 

    If you dislike the feeling of being trapped in a mattress, then you’ll be happy with the Zinus Performance Plus. It has a high score of 8.5/10 on the firmness scale. It hugs the midsection and spreads your weight such that you won’t feel pressure building up in the back. It is a good choice for managing back pain as it leaves you fully relaxed.

    Edge Support, Motion Transfer, and Sinkage 

    Since this is a firm bed, it is resilient in all dimensions. We tested the bed for sinkage and found that even with our heaviest sleepers; this bed can only dip to 5 inches. The bounce makes it easy for anyone to switch positions fast so heavy sleepers will feel they do not push into the firmer base support layer.

    As is to be expected with individually wrapped coils, the Zinus Performance Plus does not suffer from motion transfer. It retains any disturbance to the location it happens. This means you can share the bed and never have to wake up with each turn your partner makes.

    Edge support remains the best thing about innerspring beds. The spring coils are robust to help secure the sleeper on the entire bed. It makes it easy for heavy sleepers to use the edges since it won’t give in to the increased pressure.

     Zinus is a favorite buy, and it comes with premium quality plus a reasonable price.

    PROS

  • It offers extra firm support
  • Motion isolation is great owing to pocketed coils
  • It’s an excellent choice for heavy sleepers
  • It maintains a reasonable level of bounce to prevent trapping
  • It ships compressed in a box
  • CONS

  • The company does not offer free shipping on return products
  • It is only available in fours sizes including Twin, Full, King, and Queen
  • best innerspring mattress

    Why Sertapedic stays in this best innerspring mattress chart?

    Truth be said, innerspring beds are mostly high-priced, and if you find a low-priced one, the quality might leave little to like. But we have managed to come across a model that values quality yet it is not overpriced. The Sertapedic Innerspring Firm mattress offers excellent body support with 532 inner springs. It also uses cooling technology to ensure you won’t be sleeping hot.

    Let’s see what it’s all about.

    Construction 

    Top layer

    The Sertapedic bed excels in giving custom support. It is in four layers of comfort, support, cooling, and durability. The top boasts the exclusive pillowtop aire cushioning cover. It offers extra comfort to the inner springs to provide pain relief and all-night’s rest. It has better airflow which helps to regulate body temperature according to the surroundings.

    Second layer

    The second layer is Serta Comfort XD foam. It does a fine job of contouring to your body’s curves hence eliminating pressure points. The Serta Comfort XD foam uses advanced technology such that your body will be at the right temperature all night long. It achieves improved support over the entire length of your body.

    Third layer

    An insulator pad comes right below the comfort foam layer. If you have ever slept on an innerspring mattress without an insulator pad, perhaps you have felt springs poking into your back. That’s why Sertapedic brings in the insulator pad to offer ample cushioning. It also prevents too much cooling of the beds since the springs are not pocketed, and they allow lots of air to pass through them.

    Base layer

    The foundation support comes from 532 continuous springs with edge foam encasement. This brings lots of bounce which may be a problem for couples sharing this bed. Apart from the continuous springs, this bed retains a high level of firmness because of using thick springs.

    Firmness 

    The Sertapedic 200 scores high on the firmness scale. It rates around 6.5-7/10 meaning it does not give in to pressure quickly. It is designed to favor side sleepers mostly because it prevents pressure buildup along the back and shoulders. Back sleepers will also find it comfortable because it helps to disperse your weight on the bed’s surface. Stomach sleepers will not like the feel of Sertapedic. This is because you may sink unevenly.

    Motion Transfer, Edge Support, and Sinkage 

    This mattress has excellent edge support because of the integration of steel coils. It does not allow too much sinking such that you will feel secure when getting in and out of bed. For the sinkage, it showcases a reasonable level of dipping because the springs sit high on the mattress.

    What you will experience is lots of motion transfer. Since the coils are not wrapped in foam, this bed cannot contain disturbance. It is a good choice if you don’t have to share the bed. It ensures you can switch positions as many times as you’d love.

    PROS

  • It provides gentle cushioning with the comfort XD foam
  • It has regulated temperature owing to the insulator pad
  • The robust springs improve longevity of this bed
  • You can get the appropriate size for your specific needs
  • CONS

  • It does not have a means to isolate motion
  • It is a no-flip mattress
  • best innerspring mattress

    The Beautyrest Silver Plush is a mattress engineered to suit individual sleeping styles. It follows a sophisticated design that equals refreshing sleep every morning. We love that this bed uses intuitive technology for ergonomic support, excellent cushioning, and isolated motion transfer.

    Construction 

    Top layer

    In this 5-layer design, the top slab is airfeel foam. It is high-quality open cell foam which provides the bed with excellent breathability. It gives you a nice sleeping climate, and it saves the bed from Imprints. It cradles your body to give the support it needs from the knees, back, and shoulders.

    Second layer

    Next, we have airflow foam which also works to provide cooling to the bed. It improves the durability of the Silver plush as it helps the top layer to snap back after you switch positions.

    3-rd layer

    The third layer is gel memory foam. This is high-density foam which is less susceptible to pressure. It is highly adaptive to heat so that you can get responsive support to achy muscles. It also contributes to cool sleep thanks to the use of gel beads.

    Bottom layer

    The base support uses a pocket coil system. This is a series of wrapped coils encased in foam. They do not have any weak points as is occasioned with regular springs thus this bed can last a really long time. What’s more, they provide individual support which also limits the level of disturbance to the place you’ll be sleeping.

    Firmness 

    The Beautyrest Silver Plush provides a medium firmness feel. You will feel the cushioning provided by the upper layers as well as the support by the base layers. It expresses versatility in the type of sleepers who can use it. With the contouring ability of the upper and foundation layers, this bed can meet everyone’s sleeping needs.

    Sinkage, Motion Transfer, and Edge Support

    If you like the feeling of floating on a bed, the Silver Plush might be what you are looking to have. It steers away from the traditional feel of memory foam since the top layers are of airfeel and airflow foams. The memory foam comes in the third slab so you will have the correct bounce that prevents trapping.

    You will love that it dampens movements that come from any vigorous activity like getting out of bed. This way, you can sleep comfortably next to a partner who is having a restless night. Better still, this mattress uses steel coils to ensure you are supported even at the edges. Since it has a high profile at 12 inches, the bed does not sink deep, and you will never get that feeling like you are about to be ejected when you sleep too close to the sides.

    PROS

  • It provides pressure relief and balanced body support
  • It has the proper level of bounce while reducing motion transfer
  • The thick layers of pocketed coils create a solid base and edges
  • It achieves high cooling for a good sleeping climate
  • CONS

  • Some sleepers feel it is not as firm as indicated
  • You must use the recommended platform to ensure the warranty is applicable in case of a fault in the bed
  • best innerspring mattress

    Another popular model in the innerspring category is the Englander Finale. It stands 10 inches tall showcasing a beautiful, white bed. Although it is one of the affordable brands, this mattress does not compromise on the quality.

    Construction

    Top layer 

    The Englander finale boasts some superior quality in this 3-layered mattress. The top is a plush area of a soft and comfy material. In this layer, you will get incredible cushioning since it is the layer your body will come into contact with.

    Middle layer

    The plush top follows with a middle slab of exceptional support. It incorporates high-quality CertiPUR Certified foam in the middles layers. They ensure you remain supported, but your body will not be digging into the base layer. This bed is mostly recommended for kids and persons with a small build since it may give due to too much pressure.

    Bottom layer

    The foundation of this bed comes from 14 gauge springs. They are strong, tempered steel coils which offer zoned support. They provide some hug and contouring support which helps to relax tired muscles. The springs also move individually to stop the transfer of movement.

    Firmness

    This bed offers a high level of balance between the top and bottom layers. Because of the small profile, it may not favor heavy sleepers. But for persons of a small build, this mattress should sleep well in all positions.

    Motion Transfer and Edge Support 

    The Englander Finale has an instant response time to movements. But it will not transfer that bounce to the rest of the bed. All individual springs do not transmit motion making it amazing for quiet nights beside a tossing partner.

    This mattress uses a plush top and a foam middle layer supported by the base springs. It can give in to too much pressure because of the small, 10-inch frame.

    PROS

  • It is toxic free for use by the whole family
  • It has a quilted cover available in beige and white colors
  • The 3-one layer eliminates pressure points
  • It comes in a compact box for easy shipping and unpacking
  • CONS

  • It’s not good for medium build and heavy sleepers
  • It has only one year warranty
  • best innerspring mattress

    The Signature Sleep Signature displays some reliable specs from having a high coil count to the low gauge steel coils. It showcases durability and a high value for money seeing that you will be spending a reasonable amount to acquire a well-structured bed.

    Construction 

    Top layer

    This mattress has a decent structure in three layers. The pillow top is the first point of body contact. It is a blend of soft materials and memory foam to offer exceptional cushioning. It helps to support the body from head to toe so that you can have custom comfort.

    Medium layer

    The middle layer uses 3-zone foam. It is soft on the top but firmer as you get to the bottom layer. This slab plays a significant role when it comes to alleviating pain from the joints. More so, the back and upper body where most of the pressure builds up as you sleep.

    Bottom layer

    The contouring support comes from the 10-inch foundation of individually pocketed springs. They are low-gauge springs which indicate a high thickness level. As this layer cradles the body, it helps to spread your weight and align the spine for proper support. It’s the mattress to look for if you want to wake up rejuvenated from tired muscles.

    Firmness 

    This mattress scores 5.5/10 on the firmness scale. It is more flexible and adaptive to various sleeping positions. The foam layers are comfy and relaxing, but the base is firm. It provides even weight distribution for back and stomach sleepers. It is also a good pick for side sleepers since it hugs the areas where pressure builds up.

    Motion Transfer and Edge Support 

    This bed offers some bounce because of the coil system. But it manages to localize this bounce. This makes it possible for heavy sleepers and couples to use this bed with no fuss. It performs great as the pocketed springs provide outstanding edge support. This means you will feel secure whether you are seated on the edge or sleeping on the sides of this bed.

    PROS

  • It has a durable bamboo rayon cover
  • It exhibits hypoallergenic properties
  • It has little to no motion transfer
  • It achieves firm back support
  • CONS

  • It is a heavy mattress - you may ask for help when unpacking it
  • A few complaints about it being too soft
  • So... What is the best innerspring mattress?

    It can be tough trying to find the ideal innerspring mattress. But we hope our guide helps you out in this endeavor. These beds can offer customized support, but it all depends on the mattress design you pick. Remember that; how one mattress feels to one person might not be the same feeling you’ll get. With innerspring beds, you don’t want to take a gamble on a low-quality mattress. That’s why we’ve provided this guide so you won’t have to compromise on anything.

    Winner of our chart is Classic Brands Mercer mattress.